Judge to Determine if Zales Diamonds Are ‘Brightest’

Industry experts say there is no agreed upon standard

   

Judge to Determine if Zales Diamonds Are ‘Brightest’

Diamonds 300x227 Judge to Determine if Zales Diamonds Are Brightest Advertising claims by Zale Corp.’s (NYSE:ZLC) Zales jewelry chain are about the face a courtroom showdown.

Zale has been sued by Signet Jewelers’ (NYSE:SIG) subsidiary Sterling Jewelers over the way it markets its “Celebration Fire” stones. Sterling is accusing Zale of false advertising for claiming that the stones are the “most brilliant diamonds in the world” and is asking for an injunction to force Zale to halt its marketing campaign for the diamonds, the Wall Street Journal notes.

lawbook gavel 200x200 Judge to Determine if Zales Diamonds Are Brightest
Oakley Sues Nike, Pro Golfer Over Breach of Contract

Sterling claims that the brightness of diamonds can be scientifically measured and thus is not a subjective claim, which would be permissible under commercial law. Zale says its claims are backed by independent laboratory testing and dismissed the suit as groundless.

Industry experts said that there was no universally accepted standard for measuring the amount of light a diamond reflects and expressed skepticism over Sterling’s legal action.

The issue will be put before a federal judge in Ohio starting next week. In addition to its demand that Zale abandon its advertising claims, Sterling is also demanding millions of dollars in damages from Zale.

Shares of Zale fell more than 1% in Wednesday morning trading, while Signet shares rose fractionally.


Article printed from InvestorPlace Media, http://investorplace.com/2012/12/judge-to-determine-if-zales-diamonds-are-brightest/.

©2014 InvestorPlace Media, LLC

Comments are currently unavailable. Please check back soon.