Nobody’s going to change the mind of gold bugs, but after recording its 12th consecutive yearly gain, gold’s bullish run may be set for a pause. Here are eight reasons that put gold’s rally at risk:
1) Risk Appetite is Increasing
Since the beginning of the year, the CBOE Volatility S&P500 Index (TSE:VIX) has fallen an incredible 37% as risky investing surges. SPDR Gold Trust (NYSE:GLD), iShares Barclays 20+ Yr Treasury Bond (NYSE:TLT) and other “safe-haven” trades have slumped in value. Meanwhile, higher risk assets like Vanguard MSCI Emerging Markets (NYSE:VWO) and iShares Russell 2000 Index (NYSE:IWM) have climbed.
2) Physical Demand is Sliding
Although Q3 2012 gold demand was up 10% up from the previous quarter, it was down year-over-year. In value terms, demand was worth $57.6 billion or 14% below Q3 2011. Investment demand was 16% below the exceptional levels witnessed in Q3 2011, led by a steep drop in the bar and coin segment.
3) End of QE
Gold rallied around 70% from Dec. 2008 to Jun. 2011 during the Federal Reserve’s first two rounds of quantitative easing (QE). But how would it react without QE? All things must end and QEternity may be in its final inning. Several Fed officials, according to minutes from last month’s meeting, want to stop asset purchases, citing worries about the Fed’s bloated balance sheet and financial stability. Ending QE could put downward pressure on gold.
4) Overly Bullish Gold Sentiment
The Bloomberg News poll of traders, investors, and analysts predicting higher gold prices ( iShares Gold Trust (NYSE:IAU)) are near 75, which puts it in elevated territory. Over the past year, we’ve experienced better upside trades in gold prices when bullishness is below 50. (see chart below)
5) Rising Speculation
Open interest data from the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission shows gold call option buying is outpacing bearish puts by roughly double. When the crowd bets heavily in favor of a certain trade, usually they’re wrong.
6) Central Banks are Slowing Gold Purchases
Central banks continued to purchase gold in the third quarter, but at a slower pace; demand of 97.6 tonnes, worth $5.2 billion accounted for 9% of overall gold demand during the period. Diversification of reserve assets remains the driving force behind gold investments by central banks.
7) A Break in Momentum
Gold registered its 12th consecutive yearly gain in 2012 by rising 7%. That’s an incredible streak – its best since 1920. But in reality, gold has been in correction mode since September 2011. It’s unrealistic to expect gold prices to register yearly gains indefinitely.
8) Higher Gold Taxes in India
Bloomberg reports that India may increase taxes on gold imports to help cut its current account deficits, says Finance Minister Palaniappan Chidambaram. Why does it matter? Not only is India the world’s largest buyer of gold bullion, but less than 1% of the world’s gold is mined there. Taxes could eventually be raised from 4% to 6%. What type of impact would this have on gold prices?
Here’s another interesting fact: On a relative performance basis, we continue to see gold underperformance versus other major asset classes, including SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average (NYSE:DIA), (real estate) Vornado Realty Trust (NYSE:VNQ) and even Vanguard MSCI Europe (NYSE:VGK). Is relative underperformance a sign of strength or weakness?
The ETF Profit Strategy Newsletter outlines market sentiment along with key support/resistance levels for high probability trades in stocks, bonds, metals, and currencies.