Let Tiffany & Co. Slowly Lose Its Luster

by Tyler Craig | March 26, 2013 8:41 am

Despite last week’s strong quarterly earnings report, shares of Tiffany & Co. (NYSE:TIF[1]) look fatigued in the short-run.

News of the jewelry retailer’s fourth-quarter EPS of $1.40 was initially cheered by Wall Street causing the stock to gap higher by 3.3% on Friday. However, the euphoria quickly soured, and with TIF now down 2.7% since Friday’s open, the gains from the earnings gap have all but disappeared.

The stock has rallied 37% off its June 2012 lows and 19% year-to-date, and some analysts[2] contend the stock appears overvalued at current levels. Followers of fundamental analysis might cite the rich valuation as a reason for TIF to consolidate or perhaps retreat in the coming weeks.

TIFchart 300x232 Let Tiffany & Co. Slowly Lose Its Luster
Click to Enlarge
Technical analysis offers up a few additional reasons to be cautious. Take the post-earnings reaction, for instance. Friday’s failed rally attempt resulted in the formation of an equal pivot high at the $71 zone. While the development of a double top might not portend an imminent correction, it could at least indicate TIF is transitioning into more of a neutral trend.

TIF also is testing a short-term support level at $68. If the stock breaches this area, more downside is likely to come.

The options market offers a unique strategy to exploit the transition of TIF into a more neutral to mildly bearish trend. Rather than shorting the stock outright — which would be an aggressive bearish bet ill-suited to generate profits if the stock merely meanders sideways — we can sell an out-of-the-money vertical call spread. The short call spread (AKA the bear call spread) allows traders to bet that a stock will fail to rise above a certain level.

In the case of TIF, you could sell the May 72.50-75 call spread for 45 cents. Provided the stock remains below $72.50, the call spread will expire worthless, allowing you to pocket the initial credit received. The risk is limited to the distance between strikes minus the net credit, or $2.05. The potential return on investment for the suggested spread is 45 cents divided by $2.05, or 22%.

The beauty of the trade is that TIF doesn’t have to undergo any type of major correction. Simply consolidating for the next month will be adequate to turn a profit.

To manage the risk, you could either exit if the stock breaks above the double top at $71, or when it reaches the short call strike at $72.50.

As of this writing, Tyler Craig did not hold a position in any of the aforementioned securities.

Endnotes:
  1. TIF: http://markets.financialcontent.com/investplace./quote?Symbol=TIF
  2. some analysts: http://blogs.barrons.com/stockstowatchtoday/2013/03/22/tiffany-looks-overvalued-takeover-possible-ariel-manager-says/

Source URL: http://investorplace.com/2013/03/let-tiffany-co-slowly-lose-its-luster/
Short URL: http://invstplc.com/1fyNqze