by Charles Sizemore | September 30, 2013 11:37 am
Earlier this year, I asked if e-cigarettes would relight Big Tobacco’s prospects. My answer was an unequivocal “no.”
Rather than being a durable growth business for Altria (MO), Reynolds American (RAI) or Lorillard (LO), e-cigarettes seem to be yet another way to help people stop smoking — a trendier version of a nicotine patch or Nicorette gum, if you will.
And because (as non-tobacco products) e-cigs were almost completely unregulated, they eroded another long-term competitive advantage for the existing players in the industry: high barriers to entry.
Outside of weapons, tobacco stocks play in probably the most regulated industry on the planet. An onerous regulatory regime favors large existing players with the size and political influence to navigate the red tape, and has the effect of snuffing out smaller players and would-be upstarts. This is one of the reasons that, despite decades of punitive taxes and lawsuits and an ever-shrinking customer base, tobacco stocks are still wildly profitable. (In the special case of tobacco, the ban on advertising also gives established brands with name recognition an insurmountable advantage over would-be upstarts.)
But in the wild, wild west of unregulated e-cigarettes, more than 250 brands currently are on the market, and they have little or no restrictions on their sale or advertising.
Plus, in a shocking marketing failure for companies that are normally run like well-oiled machines, Big Tobacco largely botched the e-cigarette branding game. As I wrote in June, Altria — the maker of the iconic Marlboro brand (among others) — launched its new e-cig under the brand name MarkTen. Take a look at the brand’s website. There is no mention of Altria, Philip Morris USA or Marlboro.
However, the unregulated free-for-all might be quickly coming to an end.
The attorneys general for 37 states, Puerto Rico, Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands have petitioned the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to regulate e-cigarettes as if they were tobacco products. Among their concerns are the attractiveness of e-cigs — some of which are fruit-flavored like a hookah water pipe — to children and teenagers. According to the Centers for Disease Control, 1 in 10 high school students tried an e-cigarette in 2012.
And it’s not just American authorities. On Oct. 8, the European Parliament is expected to vote on a new tobacco directive that would treat e-cigarettes as a medicine and subject them to strict regulation.
We should have seen this coming. Call it an adaptation of Maslow’s Hammer: If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
After four decades of aggressively attacking tobacco smoking as a social ill, it’s natural that regulators will clamp down on something that “looks like tobacco,” even if it is smokeless and likely no more harmful than my (admittedly excessive) coffee habit.
Ironically, this modestly good news for Big Tobacco. Regulation should slow down the trend of smokers ditching their cigarettes for e-cigs. And within the e-cigarette universe, the major tobacco stocks will have a massive advantage over smaller upstarts. Altria knows a thing or two about navigating rough regulatory seas — it can transfer that knowledge to their MarkTen e-cig brand far more easily than a new upstart brand can learn it.
We need to keep a little perspective, though. E-cigarettes still only make up about 1% of traditional cigarette sales, and cigarette sales continue to sink lower. To the extent that tobacco is investable, it is a no-growth dividend-and-buyback story.
Tobacco is not — and never will be again — a growth story.
Sizemore Capital is long ECON. Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA, is the chief investment officer of the investment firm Sizemore Capital Management. As of this writing, he was long MO. Click here to receive his FREE 8-part investing series that will not only show you which sectors will soar but also which stocks will deliver the highest returns. The series starts November 5 and includes a FREE copy of his 2014 Macro Trend Profit Report.
Source URL: http://investorplace.com/2013/09/e-cigs-e-cigarettes-tobacco-stocks/
Short URL: http://invstplc.com/1nv5M8v
Copyright ©2016 InvestorPlace Media, LLC. All rights reserved. 700 Indian Springs Drive, Lancaster, PA 17601.