“The #1 Tech Opportunity of the Decade”

On February 8th, Luke Lango is making his biggest call of 2023. He’s recommending technology (that you’ve likely never heard of) that could help 122 million people… And mint up to $3 trillion in wealth.

Wed, February 8 at 8:00PM ET

Fortegra Financial: This ‘Best Stock’ Goes Out on Top

I named Fortegra Financial (FRF) as my pick in the 10 Best Stocks for 2014 contest back in Dec. Even though we have one more quarter left in the year, I can already say the story played out just as I expected.

best-stocks-2014To briefly recap why I chose FRF to begin with, financial stocks had performed extremely well in 2013. So, naturally I was watching this sector closely. FRF wasn’t a traditional bank or financial company, but both its growth and takeover potential stood out to me.

Fortegra provides payment protection and other insurance services. I liked that FRF management had worked to expand product offerings in the fastest-growing areas of insurance. I liked that Fortegra had reported good earnings every quarter since coming public in late 2010.

Although Fortegra did disappoint analysts at times, there was never a quarter where growth was not recorded, and I didn’t see why this growth wouldn’t continue. I also  liked the acquisitions FRF management had made since 2009, which I expected to keep boosting growth in the future.

While Fortegra was spending $100 million on acquisitions, I also knew it could become an acquisition target. Summit Partners owns 63% of FRF, and I knew they weren’t pleased that FRF stock was selling well below its 2010 IPO price of $11.50. Management had indicated it would consider any and all options to help boost the stock price — presumably including a selling Fortegra.

That’s exactly what happened.

On Aug. 12, Fortegra popped 40% on news that Tiptree Financial (TIPT) would acquire it for $10 a share. FRF stock immediately went from $7 to $10.

Tiptree got a heck of a deal, as Fortegra is worth more than $10 a share. FRF’s fundamentals were really starting to straighten out as Fortegra reported its second strong quarter in a row. Fortegra’s earnings grew nearly 55%, and net revenues increased 5.2%. The number of insurance premiums written jumped 20.2%, which indicated continued strong revenue performance in the future.

Taking all those numbers into account, FRF has a reasonable shot at earning $1 a share on a cash basis in 2015. So, Tiptree is getting a good deal at 10 times cash earnings. That’s not an uncommon multiple for financial stocks, but Fortegra deserves better because it doesn’t assume the credit or underwriting risk of a typical financial company.

Still, I’m very happy that my 2014 pick worked out as I expected. FRF closed at $8.27 on Dec. 31 and will finish the year with a solid 20% return.

More From InvestorPlace 

Hilary Kramer is the editor of GameChangers, Breakout Stocks Under $10 and High Octane Trader.

Article printed from InvestorPlace Media, https://investorplace.com/2014/10/frf-cash-tiptrees-acquisition-fortegra/.

©2023 InvestorPlace Media, LLC