3 Reasons Not to Give Up on Mutual Funds

ETFs have numerous advantages ... but not every advantage

    View All  
3 Reasons Not to Give Up on Mutual Funds

Building on the notion that active management can be a very compelling reason to own a fixed-income vehicle in the form of a mutual fund vs an ETF, many of these funds engage in a sophisticated approach that cannot be replicated in the form of an ETF due to regulatory challenges.

The use of futures, swaps, options or other inverse strategies are tools that active fund managers employ to control existing holdings or seek out alternative opportunities. I won’t further the debate of whether they’re effective portfolio management tools in every market, but I will say they often allow managers to increase or reduce risk and exposure within a portfolio more dynamically, or for a shorter time frame than would otherwise be efficient. Excellent examples can include mutual funds that adapt to changes in the interest-rate cycle, such as we are experiencing right now.

Owning one of the aforementioned funds would insulate an investor’s risk to declining bond prices, thereby overcoming a common pitfall of passively managed strategies.

The ‘Flash’

I remember May 6, 2010, like it was yesterday. I think every active portfolio manager using ETFs remembers that day.

Voltaire’s ominous quote describing the anatomy of a lightning bolt probably sums it up the best. As flashes of red began to touch down in the derivatives market, a thunderbolt of selling extended thought the entire investment landscape. Bid/ask spreads on even the most unshakable, stalwart stocks widened to levels that sent investors with automated stop-loss protection over a cliff, without them even knowing it. ETFs with net asset values in the 20s or 30s saw trades flow through at just 1 cent.

It was an investor’s worst nightmare that later became known as the “flash crash,” and with automated trading systems still making up a strong share of daily trading volume, I doubt it will go down in history as a one-time event.

Naturally, the one type of fund unaffected by the many trading glitches was the one that trades only once per day, and not during market hours — the open-ended mutual fund.

After stocks had regained their footing during the latter stages of the trading day, all that were affected were those ETFs that traded off their respective net asset values. Granted, had you not had automated stops you could have emerged just fine, but ETFs have gone through other periods where they haven’t been able to maintain a tight tracking margin. That’s something that all ETF investors should heed caution to, but something mutual fund investors needn’t fear.

Michael Fabian is Managing Partner and Chief Investment Officer of Fabian Capital Management. Get more investor insights from Fabian Capital, visit their blog.


Article printed from InvestorPlace Media, http://investorplace.com/2013/08/3-reasons-not-to-give-up-on-mutual-funds/.

©2014 InvestorPlace Media, LLC

Comments are currently unavailable. Please check back soon.