Facebook (FB) climbs to new highs on Q2 beat >>> READ MORE

What Does Bruce Berkowitz See in SHLD?

Fairholme Capital owns more than one-fifth of SHLD

    View All  

However, as Chad Brand points out in this Dec. 4 blog, Baker Street seems to have put an awfully optimistic spin on the value of SHLD real estate. Case in point: In September, Baker Street estimated that Sears Canada’s (SEARF) Toronto Eaton Centre lease was worth $590 million. But in late October, Sears Canada announced it was terminating leases in five stores including the flagship in downtown Toronto for $400 million — substantially less than Baker Street’s projections.

Apply the same “realistic” valuation on all of SHLD’s properties and you get far less upside.

Long-Term Picture

Speculation exists that Eddie Lampert wants to get his hands on all the shares of SHLD that Fairholme doesn’t already own. To do that, he’ll continue to buy SHLD stock whenever its value is cheap (i.e., when it’s $40 as opposed to $60 like it was shortly after Baker Street’s optimistic valuation) and available. Bruce Berkowitz obviously sees the passing of time as Sears’ friend and not its enemy or he’d be pressing Lampert to speed up this process.

Sure, it’s a mess operationally. But as long as SHLD can keep the lights on at its top 350 locations that it owns as well as the top 50 that it leases over time, it should be able to generate real estate divestitures in excess of the $7.3 billion Baker Street currently estimates on those properties. The longer SHLD waits, the better off it might be.

Bottom Line

Nordstrom (JWN) has approximately 25.5 million square feet of space, both owned and leased — just one-tenth SHLD’s massive holdings. It’s clear that if Sears continues to operate retail stores it will be in a much smaller package. To do that, it needs time to evaluate which properties are better sold and which can continue operating.

Stores like the Eaton Centre lease are no-brainers to sell because Sears is no longer (not that it ever was) a downtown shopping destination. It’s a place for people living in smaller towns who don’t have a lot of options when it comes to shopping.

How many of these exist? I would think quite a few.

Recently I wrote that Warren Buffett’s legacy should be evaluated only after the entirety of Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B) is sold off in a controlled sale, maximizing shareholder value. A process that would likely take years. Edward Lampert’s legacy, like Buffett’s, likely will follow the same course.

Until SHLD deals out its excess real estate, it’s hard to know whether Berkowitz’s bet pays off. Seven years in, he’s still biding his time. But if the sales pay off as he expects — which is plausible, if not necessarily guaranteed — the resulting bump in SHLD stock will make him look like a very smart man in retrospect.

As of this writing, Will Ashworth did not own a position in any of the aforementioned securities.

Article printed from InvestorPlace Media, http://investorplace.com/2014/02/bruce-berkowitz-see-shld/.

©2017 InvestorPlace Media, LLC