Forget Spy vs. Spy, Try SPY vs. Apple

Advertisement

Looks like options trading investors have a new group of options coming down the pike from Nasdaq OMX Group (NASDAQ: NDAQ). This, from Brendan Conway at The Wall Street Journal:

“The exchange got the nod to list and start trading options on the so-called “Alpha Indexes,” a Securities and Exchange Commission filing late Tuesday shows. The indexes, co-created by the designer of the first CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) “fear gauge,” track popular stocks’ performance versus a broader market benchmark. By listing options, Nasdaq hopes to let investors generate returns even when markets are down, with options that profit when Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) or Citigroup (NYSE: C) outperforms even a plunging stock market.

“In stock options, you’re actually making two bets. You’re betting that Apple will rise relative to the market, and also that the market will go up,” VIX designer Robert Whaley, now a professor at Vanderbilt University’s Owen Graduate School of Management, told Dow Jones Newswires at the indexes’ October unveiling. “With these, you’re getting a more precise investment in something you have some knowledge about.”

The Alpha Indexes let you make a bet on one product versus another, but with just one trade. In other words, let’s say you want to capture the return of Apple over SPY … well, you’re in luck, there’s:

AVSPY – or the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSE: SPY) versus AAPL.

And given the bull market in AAPL, you’ve done quite well with that one. Not quite so much with the other three that go against SPY.

EVSPY, or SPY versus the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index (NYSE: EEM)

TVSPY, or SPY versus iShares Barclays 20+ Year Treasury Bond (NYSE: TLT)

GVSPY, or SPY versus SPDR Gold Trust (NYSE: GLD)

And for good measure, there’s a play on Citi vs. XLF, with:

CVXLF, or Citi versus Financial Select Sector SPDR (NYSE: XLF).

Not sure I totally see the demand to play C versus financials, but the others do have some appeal imho.

Obviously you can construct any of these on your own. And in any form you want. You can go long AAPL calls vs. short SPY, long AAPL calls vs, short SPY calls, long AAPL puts vs. SPY puts, or … you get the idea.

The “Alpha” Index itself gets you essentially long one stock versus short the other. If you want an option play, it clearly makes life easier to use “Alpha” options. If you use calls (or puts) on both, you not only have bet on direction, you’ve also bet on the relationship of volatility of one to the other. So an “alpha” bet adds a layer of  simplicity.

The catch? Well, who knows the liquidity. I can’t imagine they catch fire so fast. These “alpha’s” are just indices now, and rather ignored ones. Letting the world trade them will generate some attention. But how much, we don’t know.

Also, they’re European exercise and cash settled, for the obvious reason that there’s nothing to deliver just yet. That works fine sometimes, at least until you start getting the big players messing with settlement prices. The plus side though is that an index base will not have the inevitable problems that an exchange traded fund or exchange traded note will encounter. Such as fees, and problems tracking the underlying.

All in all I find this a very interesting idea. Not sure I’d go trade these so fast though. Wait and see if they get some traction.

Follow Adam Warner on Twitter @agwarner


Article printed from InvestorPlace Media, https://investorplace.com/2011/02/forget-spy-vs-spy-try-spy-vs-apple/.

©2024 InvestorPlace Media, LLC